[I-House Press] Demystifying Pearl Harbor: A New Perspective from Japan

Demystifying Pearl Harbor: A New Perspective from Japan
By Iguchi Takeo (Professor Emeritus, Shobi-Gakuen University)

Translated by David Noble
First English edition, 2010.
366 pages, hardcover.
ISBN 978-4-903452-19-7
Originally published in Japanese in 2008 by Chuokoron Shinsha as Kaisen shinwa.
3,143 yen / Discount rate*: 2,200 yen (inclusive of tax)
*Discount rates are applicable for IHJ members.
click to order

What led Japan to its disastrous war against the United States and Britain? Why was the notification delayed, giving rise to American vilification of Japan’s attack on Pearl Harbor without a declaration of war?

In this ground-breaking book, former Japanese diplomat Iguchi Takeo looks at the failure of diplomacy before examining in depth Japan’s final memorandum to the United States and its delayed transmission to the Japanese embassy in Washington and thus to the US State Department. He finds that individuals in the military (and possibly the Foreign Ministry) colluded to delay Foreign Ministry telegrams to Washington to protect the surprise attacks on Pearl Harbor and in Southeast Asia; the necessity of responding to an eleventh-hour telegram from President Roosevelt to the emperor also contributed to the delay. After Japan’s defeat, and faced with the International Military Tribunal for the Far East (the Tokyo Trial), such collusion was covered up in order to evade personal responsibility and protect superiors. Thus the whole issue of responsibility was left in a maze of silence and conflicting testimony.

Postwar conspiracy theories lay the blame for war on Roosevelt’s provoking Japan into war and questioned the “victors’ justice” of the Tokyo Trial. And the blame for the delay in notification of termination of negotiations was placed on the Japanese embassy in Washington. Although such myths might be politically expedient and psychologically comforting, Iguchi believes it is crucial to move beyond “victors’ history” or “losers’ history“ to uncover the impartial historical truth—both for their own sake and for future generations at home and abroad.

From this volume’s Foreword

This is an extremely valuable addition to the literature on Japan’s Pearl Harbor attack. The author has three qualities in unique combination that no one else shares. First, on 7 December 1941, he was in Washington, DC, where his father worked for the Japanese embassy. Having experienced the humiliating shift from a privileged foreign visitor to a despised enemy alien, he personally and passionately believes that the war between the two countries was an avoidable tragedy. Second, he himself later became a diplomat and is intimately familiar with the bureaucratic workings of the Foreign Ministry and of overseas embassies. Third, he also is a specialist in international law, having written and taught on the subject for many years after retiring from the foreign service. Thus he is in a position to evaluate the legal aspect of the US-Japanese controversy that ultimately brought about Pearl Harbor. To these special circumstances Mr. Iguchi adds many years of his own research in Japanese and US archives as well as personal interviews with officials and military personnel who were directly or indirectly involved in the Pearl Harbor drama. The result is an up-to-date, reliable, and persuasive history of the episode.

—Iriye Akira, Harvard University

From The Japan Times, editorial

Mr. Takeo Iguchi writes that under military pressure, the Japanese Foreign Ministry not only withdrew a proper ultimatum and instead decided to notify the Unites States that negotiations were over, but also delayed sending the notice to its Washington embassy for 15 hours before the attack. He convincingly shows that the ministry left Ambassador Kichisaburo Nomura out of the loop on the attack plan.

—The Japan Times, editorial of December 8, 2008.